Summary: (DOC #191) Explains CW finances and why the CW refuses to apply for tax exempt status. Cites Ammon Hennacy and Karl Meyer's tax resistance as nonviolent protest against war. Upholds the principle that governments should never do what small bodies can accomplish.
The Catholic Worker has received a letter from the
Internal Revenue Service stating that we owe them $296,359 in
fines, penalties, and unpaid income tax for the last six years.
As the matter stands right now, there might be a legal battle
with delays and postponements which may remind us of Dickens'
Bleak House. Or, since we will not set up a defense committee
to campaign for funds, it may terminate swiftly in the confiscation
of our property and our bank account (never very large). Our farm
at Tivoli and the First Street house could be put up for sale
by government agents and our C.W. family evicted.
Perhaps no one here at St. Joseph's House realizes
the situation we are in right now as keenly as I do, having seen
so many evictions in the Depression - furniture, clothes, kitchen
utensils piled up on the streets by landlords' marshals. The
Communists used to demonstrate and forcibly move the belongings
of the unfortunate people back into the tenements, but our Catholic
Worker staff, a handful of us, begged money and rented other apartments
for eight to fifteen dollars a month and moved the evicted families
there. What a job! It exhausts me to think of it.
I can only trust that this crisis will pass. Just
as we believe that God, our Father, has cared for us, I am sure
that some way will be found either to avert the disaster of for
us to continue to care for our old, sick, helpless, hungry, and
homeless if it happens.
One of the most costly protests against war, in terms
of long-enduring personal sacrifice, is to refuse to pay federal
income taxes which go for war. The late Ammon Hennacy, one of
our editors, was a prime example of this. He earned his living
at agricultural labor, always living on a poverty level so as
not to be subject to taxes, though he filed returns. Another of
our editors, Karl Meyer, recently spent ten months in jail for
what the I.R.S. called fraudulent claims of exemption for dependents.
He ran the C.W. House of Hospitality in Chicago for many years,
working to earn the money to support the house and his wife and
children. Erosanna Robinson, a social worker in Chicago, refused
to file returns and was sentenced to a year in prison. While in
prison she fasted and was forcibly fed. It will be seen that tax
refusal is a serious protest. Wars will cease when we refuse to
pay for them (to adapt a slogan of the War Resisters International).
The C.W. has never paid salaries. Everyone gets board,
room, and clothes (tuition, recreation included, as the C.W. is
in a way a school of living). So we do not need to pay federal
income taxes. Of course, there are hidden taxes we all pay. Nothing
is ever clear-cut or well defined. We protest in any way we can,
according to our responsibilities and temperaments.
(I remember Ammon, a most consistent, brave, and
responsible person, saying to one young man, "For the love
of the Lord, get a job and quit worrying about taxes. You need
to learn how to earn your own living. That is most important for
We have to accept with humility the fact that we
cannot share the destitution of those around us, and that our
protests are incomplete. Perhaps the most complete protest is
to be in jail, to accept jail, never to give bail or defend ourselves.
In the fifties, Ammon, Charles McCormack (our business
manager at the C.W.), and I were summoned to the offices of the
I.R.S. in New York to answer questions (under oath) as to our
finances. I remember I was asked what happened to the royalties
from my books, money from speaking engagements, etc. I could only
report that such monies received were deposited in the C.W. account.
As for clothes, we wore what came in; my sister was generous to
me - shoes, for instance.
Our accounts are kept in this way: Contributions,
donations, subscriptions that come in daily are entered in one
book. The large checkbook tells of bills paid, of disbursements.
Since we send out an appeal once or twice a year, we have to
file with our state capital, pay a small fee, and give an account
of monies received and how they were spent. We always comply with
this state regulation because it is local - regional. We know
such a requirement is to protect the public from fraudulent appeals
and we feel our lives are open books - our work is obvious. And
of course our pacifism has always been obvious - a great deal
of nonviolence to be worked toward.
Christ commanded His followers to perform what Christians
have come to call the Works of Mercy: feeding the hungry, giving
drink to the thirsty, clothing the naked, sheltering the harborless,
visiting the sick and prisoner, and burying the dead. Surely a
simple program for direct action, and one enjoined on all of us.
Not just for impersonal "poverty programs," government-funded
agencies, but help given from the heart at a personal sacrifice.
And how opposite a program this is to the works of war which starve
people by embargoes, lay waste the land, destroy homes, wipe out
populations, mutilate and condemn millions more to confinement
in hospitals and prisons.
On another level there is a principle laid down,
much in line with common sense and with the original American
ideal, that governments should never do what small bodies can
accomplish: unions, credit unions, cooperatives, St. Vincent de
Paul Societies. Peter Maurin's anarchism was on one level based
on this principle of subsidiarity, and on a higher level on that
scene at the Last Supper where Christ washed the feet of His Apostles.
He came to serve, to show the new Way, the way of the powerless.
In the face of Empire, the Way of Love.
And here in small groups we are trying to talk of
these things in the midst of the most powerful country in the
world, during wartime, with the imminent threat of being crushed
by this government, all because of principle, a principle so small
and so important! It is not only that we must follow our conscience
in opposing the government in war. We believe also that the government
has no right to legislate as to who can or who are to perform
the Works of Mercy. Only accredited agencies have the status of
tax-exempt institutions. After their application has been filed,
and after investigation and long delays, clarifications, intercession,
and urgings by lawyers - often an expensive and long-drawn-out
procedure - this tax-exempt status is granted.
As personalists, as an unincorporated group, we will
not apply for this "privilege." We have explained to
our donors many times that they risk being taxed on the gifts
they send us, and a few (I can only think of two right now) have
turned away from us. God raises up for us many a Habakkuk to
bring his pottage to us when we are in the lion's den, or about
to be, like Daniel of old.
Frankly, we do not know if it is because the government
considers us a danger and threat that we are faced by this crisis.
I beg the prayers of all our readers, whether they are sympathetic
to us or not. I'm sure that many will think me a fool indeed,
almost criminally negligent, for not taking more care to safeguard,
not just the bank account, but the welfare of all the lame, halt,
and blind who come to us.
Our refusal to apply for exemption status in our
practice of the Works of Mercy is part of our protest against
war and the present social "order" which brings on wars
This text is not copyrighted. However, if you use or cite this text please indicate the original publication source and this website (Dorothy Day Library on the Web at http://www.catholicworker.org/dorothyday/).
Day, Dorothy. "We Go On Record: CW Refuses Tax Exemption".
The Catholic Worker, May 1972, 1,3,5.
The Catholic Worker Movement.
Interested in printing this article in a printer friendly format?
Use your browsers back feature to return to this page.